The Complete Baby Mattress Buying Guide

Table of Contents

Spread the love

Choosing the right mattress for your baby is one of the most important safety decisions you’ll make as a new parent. With babies spending up to 50% of their time sleeping during their first two years, the mattress you select will play a crucial role in your little one’s safety, comfort, and development. This comprehensive guide will walk you through everything you need to know about buying a baby mattress in the UK, from the latest 2025 safety regulations to sizing, materials, and expert recommendations.

⚠️ Critical Safety Message: What Every Parent Must Know

The Lullaby Trust’s Essential Safety Guidance:

The safest mattresses are firm, flat and protected by a waterproof cover. They should be completely flat with no raised or cushioned edges or sides.

NHS Official Recommendation:

Babies need “a firm mattress that fits the cot snugly without leaving spaces around the edges”.

The Statistics That Matter:

There are more than 200 sudden infant deaths every year in the UK. Some research has found a higher risk of SIDS when using a second-hand mattress from outside the family home. Your mattress choice is literally a life-or-death decision.

Why Your Baby’s Mattress Choice Is Critical for Safety

Your baby’s mattress isn’t just about comfort – it’s fundamentally about preventing serious risks, including Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) and suffocation. Evidence shows that sleeping a baby on anything but a firm, flat surface or using soft, heavy bedding can increase the risk of sudden infant death syndrome.

Critical Safety Fact: Having a firm mattress reduces the risk of suffocation if your baby rolls onto their face, which is mostly a concern between four and 12 weeks, when rolling over typically begins.

Revolutionary Changes: UK Baby Mattress Safety Regulations 2025

Game-Changing Regulatory Updates Coming October 2025

A landmark change is about to transform the UK baby mattress landscape. The Furniture and Furnishings (Fire) (Safety) (Amendment) Regulations 2025, which will come into force on 30 October 2025, represent a fundamental shift in how baby mattresses are regulated.

The most significant change:

Baby mattresses with dimensions less than 170cm in length and 75cm in width will be exempt from fire safety requirements. This groundbreaking amendment removes the need for chemical flame retardants in baby mattresses, dramatically reducing babies’ exposure to harmful chemicals during their most vulnerable developmental stage.

This statutory instrument was laid in Parliament on 30 April 2025, but in accordance with the United Kingdom’s obligations as a member of the World Trade Organisation (WTO), includes a deferral period of 6 months to fulfil international obligations.

What This Means for Parents Shopping Now vs. After October 2025

If you’re buying before October 30, 2025:

Current mattresses may still contain chemical flame retardants, but all safety standards remain the same.

If you’re buying after October 30, 2025:

New mattresses will have reduced chemical content while maintaining identical safety standards for mechanical and structural safety.

Expert Advice:

The safety requirements for firmness, fit, and construction remain unchanged regardless of when you purchase.

Current Safety Standards You Must Know

Primary Safety Standards

BS EN 16890:2017+A1:2021 remains the primary safety standard for cot mattresses. Released on July 12, 2021, this standard includes rigorous testing for:

Mechanical hazards, including entrapment, suffocation, and choking risks
Firmness requirements to prevent suffocation
Durability to ensure long-term safety
Hygiene and cleanliness standards

BS EN 716 is the key safety regulation governing baby cots and mattresses in Europe. This standard ensures that baby cots are designed and constructed to provide a secure sleeping environment, minimising risks associated with entrapment, suffocation, or injury.

Critical Safety Testing Requirements

The mattress components have stringent regulations, such as any gaps found in a mattress must pass a probe test to ensure a baby’s fingers can’t get caught in it. There are also rules about the exact sizing of cot mattresses so a baby’s fingers or hands can’t get trapped down the edge, and that the mattress doesn’t exceed 10cm in depth so the baby can’t climb out of the cot.

Standard UK Baby Mattress Sizes and Critical Fit Requirements

UK Standard Mattress Sizes

Mattress Type	Dimensions	Suitable For	Age Range
Cot Mattress	120cm x 60cm	Traditional cots	Birth to 18-24 months
Cot Bed Mattress	140cm x 70cm	Convertible cot beds	Birth to 4-5 years

A split image showing a hand pressing down on a soft white mattress on the left and a measuring tape indicating the width of 3, placed in between wooden crib slats on the right.

⚠️ Critical Safety Fit Requirements

BS EN 716 Safety Standard: There should be no more than a 30mm gap between the mattress and the cot frame. This tight fit is necessary to prevent the baby from becoming trapped in any gaps, which could lead to suffocation or other injuries.

How to Measure Safely:

Take a tape measure and check the length and width of the mattress at multiple places
Measure both your cot’s internal dimensions precisely
Ensure the mattress fits with gaps no larger than 30mm (3cm)
Test fit by trying to insert more than two fingers between the mattress and the frame – if you can, the gap is too large

Safety Alert: Which? Research found that 24% of second-hand mattresses had dangerous gaps between the mattress and cot bed frame, representing a serious entrapment hazard.

Essential Safety Features Every Baby Mattress Must Have

Firmness: The Life-Saving Requirement

Critical Safety Standard: Your baby’s head should sink no more than a few millimetres into a mattress. The mattress should be firm enough that if your baby rolls onto their front, they cannot bury their face into the mattress and suffocate.

How to Test Firmness Properly – Expert Method

The Professional Hand-Press Test:

Press down firmly on the mattress centre with your palm
When you press down, there should be resistance, and the mattress should spring back immediately after you remove your hand
There should be no lasting indentation whatsoever
Test both the centre and edges for consistent firmness
If your hand leaves any indentation, the mattress is too soft and unsafe

Critical Safety Data: Which? Research revealed that 9% of new mattresses and 25% of second-hand mattresses developed dangerous indentations during use. This represents a serious suffocation risk and indicates the mattress has lost its essential firmness.

Thickness and Depth Standards

Safety Requirement: UK safety experts recommend that baby mattresses should be between 8-10cm thick. BS EN 716 requires that mattresses don’t exceed 10cm in depth so the baby can’t climb out of the cot.

Waterproof Protection Requirements

Essential Feature: Use a mattress with a waterproof cover. This will help keep the mattress clean and dry because you can wipe the cover. Look for removable, machine-washable covers that can be cleaned at 60°C to eliminate dust mites and bacteria.

Step-by-Step Baby Mattress Decision Framework

Phase 1: Safety Assessment (Non-Negotiable)

Step 1: Verify Safety Standards

✅ Confirm BS EN 16890:2017+A1:2021 compliance
✅ Look for British Standard certification marks
✅ Verify it’s designed specifically for babies (not toddler/child mattresses)

Step 2: Test Firmness Requirements

✅ Perform professional hand-press test (no indentation should remain)
✅ Ensure the head would sink no more than a few millimetres
✅ Check edges are as firm as the centre

Step 3: Measure for Perfect Fit

✅ Take a tape measure and check the length and width at multiple places
✅ Ensure the mattress fits with a maximum of 30mm gaps
✅ Test that you cannot fit more than two fingers in the gaps

Phase 2: Family-Specific Needs Assessment

Step 4: Budget Planning – Expert Sweet Spot

Expert Recommendation: £100-£150 provides the best balance of safety, quality, and value
Consider the total cost, including covers and protectors
Factor in replacement timeline (new baby = new mattress)

Step 5: Material Preferences

Chemical sensitivity concerns (choose natural fibres)
Maintenance preferences (removable covers)
Longevity needs (cot bed vs. cot mattress)

Step 6: Additional Features

Dual-sided firmness for a growing child
Hypoallergenic properties, if needed
Temperature regulation features

Comprehensive Material Guide with Expert Pricing

Foam Mattresses: Enhanced Safety Post-October 2025

Safety Profile: Foam mattresses will become significantly safer after October 2025 due to reduced chemical flame retardant requirements.

Expert Price Range: £20+ for basic foam options

Advantages	Considerations	Best For
Lightweight and easy to handle	Quality varies between manufacturers	Budget-conscious families
Generally more affordable	May retain heat more than natural materials	Short-term use (cot only)
Reduced chemicals after Oct 2025	Some parents prefer completely natural	First-time parents

Spring and Pocket Spring Mattresses

Safety Profile: Excellent durability and shape retention, maintaining firmness over extended periods.

Expert Price Range: £50+ for spring combinations

Families prioritising longevity	Considerations	Best For
Superior durability and firmness retention	Heavier than foam alternatives	Long-term use (cot beds)
Excellent airflow and breathability	Generally more expensive	Families prioritizing longevity
Responsive support	May produce slight noise	Parents wanting traditional construction

Natural Fibre Mattresses: The Chemical-Free Choice

Safety Profile: Completely chemical-free, aligning perfectly with the 2025 regulatory focus on reducing chemical exposure.

Expert Price Range: £100+ for natural materials

Advantages	Considerations	Best For
Zero chemical content	Higher initial investment	Chemical-sensitive families
Naturally hypoallergenic	May require careful maintenance	Environmentally conscious parents
Excellent breathability	Limited availability	Premium quality seekers

What to Absolutely Avoid: Critical Safety Warnings

❌ Never Use Second-Hand Mattresses

Expert Consensus: We recommend buying a new mattress for each baby. The Lullaby Trust specifically advises against second-hand mattresses.

Dangerous Statistics from Which? Research:

25% develop dangerous indentations vs. 9% for new mattresses
24% have dangerous gaps vs. 10% for new mattresses
27% have broken zips vs. 11% for new mattresses

Health Risk: Some research has found a higher risk of SIDS when using a second-hand mattress from outside the family home.

❌ Dangerous Products to Avoid Completely

Memory Foam: Temperature-sensitive properties create suffocation risks
Sheepskin Linings: Don’t use a sheepskin to line the cot, Moses basket or other sleep space
Pods or Nests: We don’t recommend pods or nests as sleeping babies should not lie on or have anything soft around their heads
Overly Soft Surfaces: Any mattress described as “plush,” “soft,” or “cushioned”

Comprehensive Maintenance and Troubleshooting Guide

Monthly Safety Inspection Checklist

Visual Inspection:

✅ Check for sagging or permanent indentations
✅ Examine the cover for tears or holes
✅ Verify all components are securely attached
✅ Assess fit within the cot frame (maximum 30mm gaps)

Firmness Testing:

✅ Perform hand-press test monthly using the expert method
✅ Check that the mattress springs back immediately after removing your hand
✅ Ensure no lasting indentations remain

Hygiene Assessment:

✅ Check for persistent odours
✅ Examine waterproof cover condition
✅ Verify cleaning effectiveness at 60°C

Cleaning and Maintenance Schedule

Weekly:

Wipe the waterproof cover with a damp cloth
Check for spills or stains requiring immediate attention

Monthly:

Remove and wash the cover at 60°C (if removable)
Rotate the mattress to ensure even wear
Perform a comprehensive safety inspection

Every 3 Months:

Deep clean according to the manufacturer’s instructions
Assess overall condition and firmness
Check the cot fit measurements using a tape measure at multiple places

Troubleshooting Common Issues

Problem: Mattress Feels Softer Than When New

Immediate Action: Perform an expert hand-press test
If Indentation Remains: Replace immediately – this is a suffocation hazard
Prevention: Rotate regularly, avoid excessive moisture

Problem: Gaps Appearing Between Mattress and Cot

Immediate Action: Measure gaps with a ruler at multiple points
If over 30mm: Stop using immediately and replace
Cause: Mattress shrinkage or cot frame expansion

Problem: Persistent Chemical Odours

New Mattress: Allow 24-48 hours for ventilation in a well-ventilated room
If odour persists: Contact the manufacturer – may indicate a defect
Never Use: If a strong chemical smell doesn’t dissipate

Problem: Waterproof Cover Damage

Minor Tears: Replace the cover immediately to maintain hygiene
Major Damage: May require full mattress replacement if core is compromised

When Immediate Replacement is Essential

Replace Immediately If:

❌ Fails expert hand-press test (indentation remains after removing hand)
❌ Gaps exceed 30mm between the mattress and the cot frame
❌ Visible sagging or permanent deformation
❌ Contamination that cannot be cleaned at 60°C
❌ Persistent chemical odours after 48 hours
❌ Any structural damage to the mattress core

The Complete Baby Mattress Buying Guide: A baby wrapped in a cream-coloured blanket sleeps in a wooden crib set in a softly lit nursery with beige curtains and a bedside table holding a lamp and a vase with pampas grass.

Budget Planning with Expert Value Analysis

Complete Cost Breakdown by Category

Price Range	Features Included	Typical Lifespan	Expert Recommendation
£50-£100	Basic foam, meets safety standards, basic cover	12-18 months	Budget option, plan for replacement
£100-£150	Premium springs or natural fibres, dual-sided, superior covers	2-3 years	Expert Sweet Spot – Best Value
£150-£250	Premium springs or natural fibers, dual-sided, superior covers	3-5 years	Long-term investment
£250-£300+	Premium natural materials, custom features, extended warranties	5+ years	Premium chemical-free choice

Total Cost of Ownership Calculator

Basic Setup Costs:

Mattress: £50-£300
Waterproof protector: £15-£30
Spare covers (if available): £20-£40
Total Initial Investment: £85-£370

Ongoing Costs:

Replacement protectors: £15-£30 annually
Professional cleaning (if needed): £30-£50
Early replacement (if quality issues): £50-£300

Expert Value Optimisation Strategies

Best Value Approach: Invest £100-£150 in a quality mattress with a removable, washable cover
Premium Strategy: Choose a £200+natural fibre mattress for chemical-free peace of mind
Budget Strategy: Select a £50-£80 foam mattress meeting all safety standards, plan for earlier replacement

Expert Recommendations for 2025

Top Safety-Focused Recommendations

Best Overall Safety Compliance: Look for mattresses specifically tested to BS EN 16890:2017+A1:2021 with clear certification documentation.
Best for Chemical-Conscious Parents: Natural coir and latex mattresses offer complete chemical-free peace of mind, especially important before October 2025 regulatory changes.
Best Budget Safety Option: Quality foam mattresses meeting all safety standards, with improved safety profiles expected after October 2025.
Best Long-Term Investment: Dual-sided cot bed mattresses (140x70cm) offering different firmness levels for newborns and toddlers.

Decision Matrix for Different Family Situations

First-Time Parents on a Budget:

Priority: Safety compliance + affordability
Recommendation: £80-£120 foam mattress with removable cover
Key Features: BS EN 16890 compliance, firm construction, waterproof cover

Chemical-Sensitive Families:

Priority: Natural materials + zero chemical exposure
Recommendation: £200+ natural fiber mattress
Key Features: Organic cotton, coir, or latex construction

Long-Term Planning for Families:

Priority: Durability + growing child adaptability
Recommendation: £150-£250 dual-sided cot bed mattress
Key Features: Different firmness levels, superior construction

Making Your Final Decision: Complete Safety Checklist

Pre-Purchase Safety Verification

Essential Safety Standards:

✅ BS EN 16890:2017+A1:2021 compliance confirmed
✅ BS EN 716 Cot safety standard alignment
✅ British Standard certification visible

Physical Safety Requirements:

✅ Firmness test passed using expert hand-press method (no indentation from hand pressure)
✅ Correct size for your specific cot (120x60cm or 140x70cm)
✅ Thickness between 8-10cm
✅ Waterproof cover included or available

Fit and Installation Safety:

✅ Gaps between the mattress and the cot frame under 30mm (measured at multiple places)
✅ Cannot fit more than two fingers in any gap
✅ Mattress sits flat with no raised edges

Post-Purchase Safety Setup

Installation Checklist:

✅ Remove all packaging materials completely
✅ Allow 24-48 hours for any odours to dissipate
✅ Install a waterproof protector before first use
✅ Verify final fit measurements in the cot using a tape measure

First Month Monitoring:

✅ Perform weekly firmness checks using the expert method
✅ Monitor for any changes in fit
✅ Check for any unusual odours or changes
✅ Ensure baby is sleeping safely (feet to foot position)

Conclusion: Your Baby’s Safety Is Worth the Investment

The upcoming October 2025 regulatory changes will make baby mattress shopping both simpler and safer for UK parents. With reduced chemical exposure requirements and continued rigorous safety standards, you can choose a mattress with confidence knowing it meets the latest safety requirements.

Remember the Critical Safety Requirements:

Firm, flat mattress with waterproof cover (The Lullaby Trust guidance)
Perfect fit with no more than 30mm gaps (BS EN 716 standard)
The head sinks no more than a few millimetres (NHS recommendation)
Always buy new rather than second-hand for optimal safety

Expert Budget Guidance: The £100-£150 price range provides the optimal balance of safety, quality, and value for most families. Whether you choose a basic foam mattress, benefiting from reduced chemical content or invest in a premium natural fibre option, the most important factors remain safety compliance and proper construction. Your baby will spend thousands of hours on this mattress during their most vulnerable developmental period. This investment in their safety and well-being is one of the most important you’ll make as a parent. Take time to measure your cot precisely using a tape measure at multiple places, understand the safety requirements, and don’t hesitate to contact manufacturers with questions about compliance with current safety standards. When in doubt, prioritise safety over cost – your baby’s life depends on getting this decision right.

Illustration of the text 'Frequently Asked Questions' above a cartoon baby holding a plate with vegetables, including a carrot, broccoli, and potato, next to a large question mark in a circle.

FAQs: The Complete Baby Mattress Buying Guide

What makes a baby mattress safe?

The safest mattresses are firm, flat and protected by a waterproof cover. They should be completely flat with no raised or cushioned edges or sides. Your baby’s head should sink no more than a few millimetres into a mattress. The mattress must fit the cot snugly with no more than 3cm gaps between the mattress and the cot frame to prevent entrapment.

Should I buy a new mattress or can I use a second-hand one?

Always buy a new mattress for each baby. We do not recommend buying or using a second-hand cot mattress. Research shows that cot mattresses can lose more than 25% of their firmness in just a few years of use. Some research has found a higher risk of SIDS when using a second-hand mattress from outside the family home.

What’s the difference between cot and cot bed mattress sizes?

A traditional cot fits a 60cm x 120cm mattress, whereas a cot bed fits a 70cm x 140cm mattress. The standard dimensions for UK cot bed mattresses are 140 x 70cm, while 120 x 60cm is typically for cots that do not convert to toddler beds. Always measure your cot’s internal dimensions before purchasing.

How firm should a baby mattress be?

A baby mattress should be firm and supportive. You can test firmness by pressing on the mattress centre and edges – it should spring back quickly. A firm mattress provides support for healthy bone development and reduces the risk of suffocation. If the sleeping surface is too soft, your newborn may get stuck in a dangerous position.

What thickness should I choose for a baby mattress?

The recommended thickness for a baby mattress is between 8-10cm. We recommend that your baby’s cot mattress is at least 10cm thick to ensure your baby’s weight doesn’t cause sagging through to the base underneath. This thickness provides adequate support without compromising safety.

Are foam or spring mattresses better for babies?

Spring mattresses offer more support for longer and are well-suited for cot beds used for children up to 4 years old. Foam mattresses tend to be cheaper, but some manufacturers prefer to avoid foam and chemicals, opting instead for polyester fibres or spring systems. The most important factor is ensuring the mattress meets safety standards, regardless of material.

What additional features should I look for?

Look for mattresses with waterproof covers that can be wiped clean. Choose breathable and hypoallergenic materials. Ensure the mattress has proper ventilation and consider removable, machine-washable covers. The mattress should be tested to UK safety standards and be foam and chemical treatment-free for a purer sleeping environment.

CuddleCo Lullaby Hypo-Allergenic Bamboo Cot Bed Mattress – Rated as “Best cot mattress overall” by Mother & Baby magazine

Award-winning 2025 baby mattress with dual-sided design and natural hypo-allergenic properties. Features breathable bamboo fibers for temperature regulation and waterproof side for easy transitions. Two-time Mother&Baby Gold winner.

✅ Dual-sided: soft & waterproof
✅ Natural anti-microbial protection
✅ Perfect temperature regulation
✅ Award-winning safety & comfort

Buy on Amazon UK

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means that if you click on a link and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you.